Looking for something?

Find it in our extensive resource library!

Smart Filters

  • Reset
  • Services

  • Who it's for

  • What it’s about

  • Format

View: 17226

Download: 114

Supporting a child who has selective mutism

In time, most children will become confident talkers. However, sometimes a child may continue to find talking hard, when they are not at home, for a few reasons:

  • This could be if they are learning a new language which they are not confident about using yet.
  • They may have a speech, language or communication need (SLCN) that makes talking difficult or makes them self-conscious about talking.
  • Children experience a range of emotions such as anxiety, sadness, or overwhelm which may make engaging in interactions or talking more difficult at those times.
  • For some children the difficulty with talking freely may feel more specific, and this might be selective mutism.
  • Autism and selective mutism can occur together, and sometimes it is difficult to tell the difference between them.

What is selective mutism?

A child who is consistently not able to talk freely within a school or nursery setting may have “selective mutism”. This is a fear (like a phobia) of talking in certain “settings”, usually nursery or school, or with certain people. At home, they do not have this fear reaction and they are able to speak freely and easily.

In the case of selective mutism, a child is not making a conscious choice to not talk. They want to talk but cannot.

Selective mutism is sometimes also known as “situational” mutism, but the official diagnostic term at the moment is selective mutism.

Could it be autism?

It is important to think about how autism and selective mutism can happen together. Sometimes it is difficult to tell the difference, and sometimes it is hard to describe.

A child or young person with autism might find the situation or environment they are in to be stressful, meaning they are not able to talk whilst they are there. They may be feeling overwhelmed and “shut down”. This can look just the same as, and can be called, selective mutism. It is sometimes also described as “sometimes speaking or semi speaking” for children or young people with autism, but these are not official terms.

There are different reasons why someone might find situations stressful. When they are not in that stressful situation, they may be able to explain what they find difficult. It may be due to sensory processing differences, anxiety or emotional regulation or energy levels.

Neurodivergent children and young people might find situations stressful that other people do not, so it is important we understand what is happening from their point of view.

The strategies for selective mutism in the next section are appropriate, but it is especially important to think about the following information too:

How can adults help with selective mutism?

Adults need to use a low-pressure approach. They also need to accept other forms of communication, for example, writing or typing at the times that your child is finding talking hard.

The focus needs to be on how your child is feeling in the environment, rather than on talking.

Make sure a child does not feel pressure to talk. By helping them feel comfortable in the setting, this takes away this constant feeling of fear about being asked, or expected, to talk. It is really important that all staff are aware of the strategies detailed below.

When a child is comfortable in the setting and given time, they can then take little steps towards communicating in different ways and then gradually begin to be able to talk in the setting. This must be at a pace that they can cope with.

For children who have been experiencing selective mutism for some time, these strategies remain even more crucial, but on their own may not be enough to allow a child to talk. In these cases, they may need a more structured programme of support to help them to take tiny steps towards talking.

Adopt a low-pressure approach to communication

  • Do not make it your mission to get the child to talk. Do not say “are you going to speak to me today?!” or ask them to “give talking at school a go”, “use your words or voice” today. Please do not ask that your child say “hello”, “please”, “thank you”.
  • Use a non-directive approach to communication with the child, where it does not matter whether they talk or not.
  • If your child does talk, do not make a fuss. Just carry on like they have always spoken.
  • Keep eye contact to a minimum as this reduces pressure, and it may be better to sit next to rather than opposite your child and engage in a joint activity.
  • Comment on what is happening instead of asking lots of questions as questions can feel like demands

Let your child use a means of communication that they are comfortable with

This may be signing, symbols, writing or typing, talking via a friend.

  • A picture or signing based system for children to ask for help or to go to the toilet can be introduced as an acceptable alternative for all children in the class. Registration could also include options (for all children) to either say something or put a hand up or smile.

Make routines and the environment predictable

  • What will happen when they ‘get there’ for example, social stories
  • What the plan is for example, a visual timetable
  • Which bits of the tasks are easy and which bits are more difficult
  • How they can tell you if they need a break or to stop for example, showing you an emotional regulation card
  • When there will be a break for example, a visual timetable
  • When the ‘end’ is, for example, a visual timetable

Tell your child what is expected of them during an activity

  • Task schedules such as a symbol or bullet point list of jobs
  • Things you will or will not ask them to do
  • How they can tell you if they need a break or to stop for example, showing you an emotional regulation card

Holistic support

  • Provide lots of opportunities for fun where the focus is not on talking, but is on interaction, engagement and confidence building. Encourage them to be brave, try new things, give things a go, and to not being afraid to make mistakes.
  • Support your child’s emotional regulation skills
  • Make sure that their sensory needs are met

Talk to your child about feeling worried about talking

Whoever your child is able to talk to (such as their parents or carers and staff members with whom your child has a good relationship), can talk to them about their talking. This will give reassurance that the pressure is off them, and that their anxiety is understood:

Do
  • Reassure your child that adults are here to help them feel less worried about talking.
  • Reassure them that there is no pressure to talk, and they will feel brave enough to do this when they are ready.
  • Reassure your child you will not single them out to talk in class to answer a question, or to read aloud unless they let you know they want to be chosen, for example by putting up their hand.
  • Say they can start talking as soon as they feel ready, but until then to have a good time and have fun!
  • Explain that just because talking is hard right now, this will change as they get braver and feel less worried.
Don't
  • Ask the child why they find talking hard, as they will not know.

Useful phrases to have ready

When other children tell you your child cannot talk, you could say:

  • “They are really good at talking and if we are all patient they will be able to talk here too, isn’t that right?”
  • “Of course they can talk, but right now you would prefer to listen, wouldn’t you?”

When other children ask why the child does not talk, you could say:

  • “They haven’t found her voice in school yet, but when they do, we will speak to them as if they have always spoken.”

If they put their hand up in class but then do not talk, you could:

  • Smile and wait 5 seconds. If no answer comes, calmly move the conversation on, for example “Well done, I can see you know the answer! Who else wants to have a go?”

When they speak for the first time and other children comment on this, you could say:

  • “Great idea, that sounds like fun!”
  • “We always knew they would feel like talking one day, right, what shall we do next?”

Additional resources and information

Additional resources and information

How to refer to Speech and Language Therapy

SMIRA – Selective Mutism Information and Resource Association

A training video for parents, carers and teaching staff on Selective Mutism – what is it and what helps?

Time: 38 minutes

3 YouTube videos by Lucy Nathanson (Confident Children)

My child doesn’t talk at school

Time: 3 minutes

What is Selective Mutism?

Time: 4 minutes

The Do’s and Don’ts when interacting with a child with Selective Mutism

Time: 8 minutes

3 recommended books

The Selective Mutism Resource Manual (2nd Edition) by Maggie Johnson and Alison Wintgens. ISBN 9781909301337.

Why doesn’t Alice talk at school?

Can I tell you about Selective Mutism? A guide for friends, family and professionals by Maggie Johnson and Alison Wintgens. ISBN: 9781849052894.

Kent Community Health NHS Foundation Trust offer a series of online training recordings about Selective Mutism which can be accessed here: https://www.kentcht.nhs.uk/childrens-therapies-the-pod/speech-and-language-therapy/selective-mutism/

Contact us

For more information please contact the Speech and Language Therapy Service at Flockton House on 0114 226 2333.

Is something missing from this resource that you think should be included? Please let us know

Contact us

Disclaimer

Please note: this is a generic information sheet relating to care at Sheffield Children’s NHS FT. These details may not reflect treatment at other hospitals. This information is not intended as a substitute for professional medical care. Always follow your healthcare professionals’ instructions. If this resource relates to medicines, please read it alongside the medicine manufacturer’s patient information leaflet. If this information has been translated into another language from English, efforts have been made to maintain accuracy, but there may still be some translation errors. If you are unsure about any of the guidance in this resource or have specific questions about how it relates to your child, always ask your healthcare professional for further advice.

Resource number: SL83

Resource Type: Article

How useful did you find this resource?*

Sheffield Children's logo Right aligned

Western Bank
Sheffield
S10 2TH

United Kingdom

Switchboard: 0114 271 7000

Interesting Facts


We’ve got a special MRI scanner just for teddies so children can see what it’s like before they have a scan.

Help to transform our extraordinary hospital into something even better.

sheffield children's hospital charity logo

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close